Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Latest News:
    • John Stevenson MP visits Digging Deeper Exhibition at Tullie, Carlisle
    • John Stevenson MP welcomes Roads Minister to Carlisle to Make the Case for an A69 Upgrade
    • Regions Big Employers Supporting 10th Anniversary Carlisle Skills Fair
    • 10th Annual Carlisle Skills Fair to be held this January
    • John Stevenson MP welcomes the 2024 National Living Wage and National Mininum Wage Rates
    • How to Support our High Streets
    • Remembrance Sunday is a Chance to Reflect but also to Focus on how to Act for Freedom
    • Oral Question: British Steel
    Subscribe
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    John Stevenson MP
    MP For Carlisle
    • Home
    • In Parliament
    • News
      1. Latest News
      2. E-Bulletins
      Featured
      18th May 20230

      John Stevenson MP for Carlisle is Hosting the Northern Nuclear Conference on 29th and 30th June 2023

      Recent
      4th December 2023

      John Stevenson MP visits Digging Deeper Exhibition at Tullie, Carlisle

      4th December 2023

      John Stevenson MP welcomes Roads Minister to Carlisle to Make the Case for an A69 Upgrade

      1st December 2023

      Regions Big Employers Supporting 10th Anniversary Carlisle Skills Fair

    • About John
    • Gallery
    • Conferences
      • Northern Nuclear Conference
      • Northern Research Group Conference
      • North East Regional Conference
      • Party Conference 2023
    • Events
    • Get In Touch
    John Stevenson MP
    You are at:Home»In Parliament»Oral Question: Onshore Wind & Devolution
    Parliament

    Oral Question: Onshore Wind & Devolution

    0
    By John Stevenson on 4th November 2015 In Parliament

    Glyn Davies (Montgomeryshire) (Con): If he will encourage the Scottish Government to devolve responsibility for onshore wind planning to Scottish local authorities. [901897]

    The Secretary of State for Scotland (David Mundell): Before I answer the question, may I begin by commending you, Mr Speaker, not just for your attendance at the Davis cup semi-final in Glasgow, but for the enthusiasm with which you got behind Team GB for that momentous win? I am sure you will join me not only in wishing our Team GB the best in the final in Ghent, but in confirming that Glasgow, as it has once again demonstrated with the world gymnastics championships, is a great sporting city.

    The UK Government have given local communities the final say on new onshore wind developments in England. Planning for onshore wind is a matter fully devolved to the Scottish Parliament and sadly the Scottish Government have kept that power to themselves. I would urge them to look closely at this Government’s policy of an affordable energy mix that also protects our natural landscapes.

    Mr Speaker: I thank the Secretary of State. I shall be there in person, all being well, to support the team.

    Glyn Davies: True devolution means that power should rest as closely as possible to the people in Scotland, in Wales and in Northern Ireland. [Interruption.] Does the Secretary of State deplore the centralising policies of the current Scottish and Welsh Governments, who seem to think they know better than the people and the communities of Scotland and Wales?

    David Mundell: I agree with my hon. Friend. The current Scottish Government are one of the most centralising Governments on record, routinely overruling the wishes of local people and local authorities. The UK Government are delivering devolution to Scotland. As Lord Smith recommended, let us see devolution delivered within Scotland.

    4 Nov 2015 : Column 948

    Ms Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh (Ochil and South Perthshire) (SNP): The Secretary of State will be aware of the case of the Binn eco park in my constituency. It has the support of the local community, and the developers worked diligently to secure planning permission from Perth and Kinross Council. Despite that support, the development is threatened by the regressive approach to support for renewable energy that the UK Government have taken, putting local jobs at risk. Will he look again at the case? The development has been penalised because of a responsible approach to community engagement on planning issues.

    David Mundell: I am always happy to look at individual cases raised by Members from Scotland. I would be delighted to meet the hon. Lady and hear more about the case she sets out.

    John Stevenson (Carlisle) (Con): Does the Secretary of State agree that the Scottish Parliament could learn a lot from the devolution debate in England? [Laughter.] Will he encourage the Scottish Parliament to devolve more responsibilities and powers to local government, which could even include elected mayors for the great cities of Scotland?

    David Mundell: I agree with my hon. Friend. The response of Scottish National party MPs says it all—they think they know best and know better than local people. Let us see local decision making. Let us see Lord Smith’s individual recommendation on devolution within Scotland honoured by the Scottish Government.

    Ian Austin (Dudley North) (Lab): In addition to this question, question after question on the Order Paper from the Nats queries the powers of the Scottish Parliament, yet the truth is this: they have missed the A&E waiting time in Scotland for six years; more than 6,000 children leave primary school unable to read properly; children from poor families get a particularly bad deal under devolution; and Scotland faces a housing crisis. When I visited Edinburgh a week or so ago, I was stunned at the level of rough sleeping in that city—it is much higher than in comparable cities. Should the Nats not be sorting out the things for which they are responsible instead of demanding all those other powers? They are not just the most centralising but the most useless—

    Mr Speaker: Order. I have been generous. We must now hear from the Secretary of State.

    David Mundell: The Scotland Bill will make the Scottish Parliament the most powerful devolved Parliament in the world. What we require now is to hear from the SNP and the Scottish Government how they will use these Parliaments. They prefer arguments about process. They do not want to tell us what they will do and they do not follow that through with action.

    Mr Speaker: I call Angus Brendan MacNeil

    Mr Angus Brendan MacNeil (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (SNP): Me?

    Mr Speaker: Yes, it is you, Sir.

    4 Nov 2015 : Column 949

    Mr MacNeil: Thank you, Mr Speaker. It was difficult to hear over the noise from Labour over there.

    As we know of course, the only damage to onshore wind comes from the right hon. Gentleman’s Government, and for me the only centralising problem in Scotland is that it is not centralised enough—if only the Scottish Government could take control of inter-island flights. Planning is working well in Scotland. In fact, perhaps the Secretary of State could commend several things in Scotland to Wales, such as the political system, under which 99% of Scottish voters rejected the Tories and 95% of Members sent back here were SNP Members. He could learn a lot from that.

    David Mundell: The hon. Gentleman could learn a lot from the leader of the Western Isles Council, who is keen to have confirmation that the Scottish Government will devolve responsibility for the Crown Estate to the Western Isles—a measure that he, as MP for the Western Isles, does not appear to support. [Interruption.]

    Mr Speaker: Order. The hon. Member for Na h-Eileanan an Iar (Mr MacNeil) is the Chair of the Energy and Climate Change Committee, and I urge him to behave in the statesman-like manner expected of such a high office holder. We might learn about onshore wind from Michelle Thomson.

    Michelle Thomson (Edinburgh West) (Ind): The provision of an extra runway for either Gatwick or Heathrow is likely to require related infrastructure improvements, to be met from the public purse. Given that the money spent will include a population share of the financial consideration from Scottish taxpayers, will it be taxation without representation or can the Secretary of State guarantee that Scottish MPs will have a vote on an extra runway?

    Mr Speaker: Order. I am genuinely trying to be helpful to Members. May I please urge them to look at the terms of the question on the Order Paper? This one is specifically about onshore wind planning. I think we must now move on.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    Oral Question: British Steel

    Written Question: Speedbump Specifications

    Written Question: Business Energy Prices

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Newsletter

    Enter your information below to stay up to date with John Stevenson's Newsletter. All emails include an unsubscribe link. You may opt-out at any time. The information you enter here will be stored in line with our Privacy Notice.

    Please wait...

    Thank you for signing up!

    • Skills & Apprenticeships
    • Infrastructure
    • Business & Investment
    • Charities
    • The NHS
    1st December 2023

    Regions Big Employers Supporting 10th Anniversary Carlisle Skills Fair

    27th November 2023

    10th Annual Carlisle Skills Fair to be held this January

    6th November 2023

    John Stevenson MP urges Local Business to Sign Up for the 10th Anniversary Carlisle Skills Fair

    19th September 2023

    “Save the Date” for John Stevenson MP’s 10th Annual Carlisle Skills Fair!

    14th April 2022

    John Stevenson MP Welcomes £4,104,659 in Funding to Level Up the Carlisle area

    2nd June 2021

    Carlisle MP Welcomes Openreach’s Full Fibre Commitment

    14th May 2021

    Carlisle MP Welcomes Announcements in Queen’s Speech

    21st April 2021

    Carlisle MP asks Rural Constituents to Take Part in Open Consultation on ‘Improving Broadband for Very Hard to Reach Premises’

    20th November 2023

    How to Support our High Streets

    16th October 2023

    John Stevenson MP visits New State-of-the-Art Komatsu Premises

    23rd June 2023

    pladis Opens New Carlisle Warehouse as part of £12m Investment

    8th April 2023

    John Stevenson MP welcomes £474,841 Investment for Carlisle from the Conservative Government’s Rural England Prosperity Fund

    2nd June 2023

    John Stevenson MP Thanks Local Charity Volunteers during Volunteers’ Week 2023

    20th January 2023

    John Stevenson MP for Carlisle welcomes News of the National Lottery King’s Coronation Fund

    15th August 2022

    John Stevenson MP on Flying Visit to Great North Air Ambulance Service

    15th August 2022

    John Stevenson MP backs Silver Sunday, the National day for Older People, Sunday 2nd October 2022

    9th August 2023

    John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle, Welcomes Government’s £600 Million Package to Help Recruitment and Retention in Social Care

    23rd February 2023

    John Stevenson welcomes Cheaper HRT for Women experiencing Menopause Symptoms

    16th February 2023

    John Stevenson MP welcomes £3m to Boost Drug and Alcohol Treatment and Recovery in Cumbria

    23rd January 2023

    John Stevenson Champions “Make The Early Diagnosis of Liver Disease Routine” Campaign

    Search by Category
    • Agriculture
    • Arts & Culture
    • Business & Investment
    • Charities
    • Communities & Local Government
    • Crime & Police
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health & The NHS
    • Housing
    • Immigration
    • In Parliament
    • Infrastructure
    • Latest News
    • Publications
    • Skills & Apprenticeships
    • Transport
    • Work & Pensions
    Latest Photos
    John with the Roads Minister by the A69
    John visiting the Roman Heads at Tullie House
    John visiting the new state-of-the-art Komatsu premises
    John sitting at table at the North East Regional Conference
    John at the North East Regional Conference
    John at Stanwix Community Centre on his Summer Tour
    John on Facebook
    John Stevenson MP

    1 day ago

    John Stevenson MP
    Wise advice from Carlisle Police - worth a read.We are urging people to be on their guard against phone fraudsters.The warning follows two incidents in Carlisle in the last three days where people received calls from people pretending to be police officers.On each occasion the person calling raised concerns that the person’s card had been used or cloned and asked them to make further phone calls.Investigations show these were not police officers and it was suspected to be an attempt to defraud the people of money.Police are asking people to be aware of the following advice.If you have any concern that the person on the phone may be a fraudster, put the phone down and call the police from a different phone on 101 for advice and guidance. If you receive a call you’re not expecting, you should be suspicious. The vital things to remember are that the police would: • Never ask you for your bank account details or PIN number over the phone. • Never ask you to withdraw money and send it to them via a courier, taxi, bank transfer or by any other means. • Never ask you to send your bank cards or any other personal property to them via courier, taxi or by any other means. • If you have any doubts about the identity of the person that you are speaking with, please put the phone down and attend the police station in person, wherever possible, to discuss the call you have received, or call a trusted number for the police using a different telephone than the one that you have been contacted on.We ask that the public please share this information with any vulnerable friends or family. If you think you have been the victim of a fraud you can report this to police on 101 and to Action Fraud on 0300 123 2040 – or by visiting their website at orlo.uk/dlnRE ... See MoreSee Less
    View on Facebook
    · Share

    Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

    John Stevenson MP

    2 days ago

    John Stevenson MP
    www.johnstevensonmp.co.uk/john-stevenson-mp-visits-digging-deeper-exhibition-at-tullie-carlisle/ ... See MoreSee Less

    John Stevenson MP visits Digging Deeper Exhibition at Tullie, Carlisle – John Stevenson MP

    www.johnstevensonmp.co.uk

    John Stevenson MP visits Digging Deeper Exhibition at Tullie, Carlisle 0 By John Stevenson on 4th December 2023 Arts & Culture John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle, last week visited the ‘Digging Deeper,...
    View on Facebook
    · Share

    Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

    About

    JOHN STEVENSON

    John was educated at Aberdeen Grammar School and Dundee University. John subsequently qualified as a solicitor in 1990. In 2010 John was elected Conservative MP for Carlisle and was re-elected with an increased majority in 2015. John was re-elected again in 2017 and 2019 with a new majority of 8319. Carlisle is the only city in Cumbria and John enjoys representing a constituency at Westminster with such a strong identity.

    Latest Posts
    4th December 2023

    John Stevenson MP visits Digging Deeper Exhibition at Tullie, Carlisle

    4th December 2023

    John Stevenson MP welcomes Roads Minister to Carlisle to Make the Case for an A69 Upgrade

    1st December 2023

    Regions Big Employers Supporting 10th Anniversary Carlisle Skills Fair

    Photo Gallery
    John with the Roads Minister by the A69
    John visiting the Roman Heads at Tullie House
    John visiting the new state-of-the-art Komatsu premises
    John sitting at table at the North East Regional Conference
    John at the North East Regional Conference
    John at Stanwix Community Centre on his Summer Tour
    John declares War on Weeds
    John shows Lord Parkinson (Minister for Arts and Culture at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport) some of Carlisle's Tourist Attractions
    John discussing Dream Placement
    John holds campaign leaflet for Progress Schools 'In My Shoes' Campaign
    John speaking with apprentices and employees at Nestle factory
    John on stairs overlooking Carlisle Skills Fair 2023
    Copyright © 2015 JOHN STEVENSON. This website is funded by Parliamentary allowances.
    • About John
    • Privacy Notice
    • Get In Touch

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.