Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Latest News:
    • John Stevenson looks forward to an Action Packed Jubilee Weekend in Carlisle
    • John Stevenson Re-elected to Chair the Parliamentary Food and Drink Group
    • John Stevenson Thanks Veterans from across the Country and Cumbria’s Residents for their Support with Carlisle’s Falklands 40 Commemorative Event
    • John Stevenson MP urges Museums across Carlisle and Cumbria to bid for Funding to Level Up Culture
    • John Stevenson Celebrates Victory in Government U-Turn on BOGOF Offers for Shoppers
    • John Stevenson MP Welcomes Campaign to Boost take up of Pension Credit in Carlisle
    • John Stevenson MP Backs Falklands Forty School Competition
    • With its New Medical School, Carlisle is going to be an Educational Destination
    Subscribe
    Facebook
    John Stevenson MP
    MP For Carlisle
    • Home
    • Coronavirus
    • News
      1. Latest News
      2. In Parliament
      3. E-Bulletins
      Featured
      14th April 20200

      The Coronavirus Crisis

      Recent
      19th May 2022

      John Stevenson looks forward to an Action Packed Jubilee Weekend in Carlisle

      19th May 2022

      John Stevenson Re-elected to Chair the Parliamentary Food and Drink Group

      17th May 2022

      John Stevenson Thanks Veterans from across the Country and Cumbria’s Residents for their Support with Carlisle’s Falklands 40 Commemorative Event

    • About John
    • Photo Gallery
    • Events & Surgeries
    • Get In Touch
    John Stevenson MP
    You are at:Home»In Parliament»Brexit Deal Debate (Day 2)
    Parliament

    Brexit Deal Debate (Day 2)

    0
    By John Stevenson on 6th December 2018 In Parliament

    John Stevenson: It is a pleasure to follow Paul Farrelly.

    In many respects, this is the classic issue for MPs—what are their priorities? Are they based on their personal view, their constituency’s view, or the view of the party that they should perhaps be following? Then, ultimately, how do they make their decision in the national interest? Generally speaking, that issue does not really crop up, but we live in unusual circumstances. We have to acknowledge that parties are fundamentally split. MPs’ views can be very much at variance with those in their own constituency. The dilemma for each and every one of us is what we, as individual MPs, believe is in the national interest.

    When I look back over the past two and a half years—I appreciate that hindsight is a wonderful thing—I see some key mistakes that have been made. There were the red lines that the Prime Minister set out. In many respects, when you go into a negotiation, you do not lay down what your views are before you enter into it. Then there was the early calling of the election when we actually had a working majority, and of course the triggering of article 50. Looking back, we should have prepared all the legislative requirements and Bills to get them passed before we even thought about triggering article 50. Indeed, we should also have had a national debate about exactly what our long-term relationship with the EU should be.

    But at the end of the day, we are where we are, and the Government are suggesting that there are now three alternatives: no deal, remain/second referendum, or their own proposal. I fully accept that we voted in 2016 to leave EU institutions, and we definitely have to respect that, but the nature of our future relationship still has to be decided, and that is a decision for Parliament. Of the three options that the Government have effectively set out, I do not support a second referendum. It would be unnecessary and divisive, and I wonder what it would achieve. I cannot see how remaining in the EU would be sensible, because it would undoubtedly be a changed relationship with our EU partners. As for no deal, I find that equally unpalatable. It is not in our country’s interests. I think it would lead to a recession and make us a poorer country. It is not in the interests of our national economy and certainly not in the interests of my constituents.

    The Government therefore have to argue that the only real option is to support their position—that is, the withdrawal agreement and the political declaration. I, like many others, have concerns about the withdrawal agreement. I do not feel a need to go into those, because they have been well expressed by other Members. I also have concerns about the political declaration, many of which have been raised. We would have two years of negotiations before we even got a deal, if we did in fact get one. I question whether the unity of the EU would hold, because its members would have competing national interests. I wonder where we would end up with those negotiations. We have to await the decision of Parliament next Tuesday to know whether that is the course we will take.

    I believe there is an alternative—a fourth option—that is acceptable to the EU and fully understood by all, and that is EFTA-EEA. Simply put, that would allow us to have an independent agricultural policy and an independent fisheries policy. We would not be part of the ECJ; the EFTA court would determine decisions. There would be no payments to the EU, and we would be a member of the single market. I have never quite understood why people are so hostile to membership of the single market. We are proposing to enter into a free trade agreement. What is a free trade agreement? It is an attempt to get rid of tariffs and regulatory differences between economies. I genuinely believe that staying in the single market is in this country’s interests. I accept that there is the issue of free movement, but we have the emergency brake under article 112 of the EEA agreement, and the reality is that more immigration comes from outwith the EU than within it, and we have absolute control over that.

    I think that proposal would have widespread support from Members on both sides of the House. It would ensure that we were actually out of the EU—out of the political project and out of any sort of union—but back to the common market ideals of old, which the people of this country have always supported.

    I remind the House that relationships change. The EU will change with our departure and will continue to change in other ways that we have not thought of. EFTA would also develop. The arrival of a large economy would change its dynamics, and it would become a much more significant player. The relationship between the EU and EFTA would change because of the arrival of a large economy, and EFTA’s importance would increase significantly.

    I make those comments on EFTA to remind the House that there is a potential alternative should the Government lose the vote next week, and it is one that I would certainly support. On Tuesday, we will have to weigh up what we as individual MPs believe is in the national interest. I certainly believe that no deal and remain are not sensible alternatives. Whether the political declaration offers us a route to a sensible future relationship with the EU is a judgment that we will all have to make on Tuesday, but should the Government’s proposal be defeated, I believe there is a genuine and real alternative.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    John Stevenson Re-elected to Chair the Parliamentary Food and Drink Group

    Oral Question: Borderlands Growth Deal Mark 2

    Oral Question: Food Security

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Newsletter

    Enter your information below to stay up to date with John Stevenson's Newsletter. All emails include an unsubscribe link. You may opt-out at any time. The information you enter here will be stored in line with our Privacy Notice.

    Please wait...

    Thank you for signing up!

    • Skills & Apprenticeships
    • Infrastructure
    • Business & Investment
    • Charities
    • The NHS
    14th April 2022

    John Stevenson MP Welcomes £4,104,659 in Funding to Level Up the Carlisle area

    6th January 2022

    “New Year, New Career Opportunities!” says John Stevenson MP for Carlisle

    17th December 2021

    John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle has Welcomed News of a Skills Boost to Support More People into Jobs

    10th November 2021

    ‘It’s not too late to sign up for the Skills Fair!’ says John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle

    14th April 2022

    John Stevenson MP Welcomes £4,104,659 in Funding to Level Up the Carlisle area

    2nd June 2021

    Carlisle MP Welcomes Openreach’s Full Fibre Commitment

    14th May 2021

    Carlisle MP Welcomes Announcements in Queen’s Speech

    21st April 2021

    Carlisle MP asks Rural Constituents to Take Part in Open Consultation on ‘Improving Broadband for Very Hard to Reach Premises’

    14th April 2022

    John Stevenson MP Welcomes £4,104,659 in Funding to Level Up the Carlisle area

    7th April 2022

    John Backs University of Cumbria and Imperial College London Plans for a New Medical School in Carlisle

    25th March 2022

    John Stevenson MP visits Carlisle Cathedral to show Support for English Tourism Week

    30th November 2021

    John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle encourages Constituents to Shop Local ahead of Small Business Saturday this Weekend

    26th October 2021

    John Stevenson MP backs Guide Dogs Campaign on the use of E-scooters

    2nd August 2021

    John Stevenson MP Supports Wetheral’s Oak Tree Animals’ Charity

    25th June 2021

    John Stevenson MP visits Buzz Bingo ahead of National Bingo Day 2021

    20th November 2020

    John Stevenson MP Praises the Government’s Coronavirus Community Support Fund for helping Local Causes in Carlisle

    7th April 2022

    John Backs University of Cumbria and Imperial College London Plans for a New Medical School in Carlisle

    3rd December 2021

    John Stevenson MP urges people in Carlisle to get their Booster Jab on ‘Boost Day’

    2nd August 2021

    John Stevenson MP Welcomes Opening of new Coronavirus Local Test Site in Carlisle

    1st July 2021

    John Stevenson, MP for Carlisle, Backs National Thank You Day adding Thanks of his Own

    Latest Photos
    John carries Commemorative Rose at Falklands Events
    John with Students on Dream Week Placement
    John with Mark Jenkinson MP and Cumbria Order
    John with Clark Door Limited supporting Family Business
    John with Rob and Claire Story of Story Decorating
    John attending meeting at Carlisle Cathedral celebrating EnglishTourismWeek21, which included tourism businesses from across Carlisle
    Search by Category
    • Agriculture
    • Arts & Culture
    • Business & Investment
    • Charities
    • Communities & Local Government
    • Crime & Police
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health & The NHS
    • Housing
    • In Parliament
    • Infrastructure
    • Latest News
    • Publications
    • Skills & Apprenticeships
    • Transport
    • Work & Pensions
    John on Facebook
    John Stevenson MP

    52 minutes ago

    John Stevenson MP
    A very early Save the Date but here it is ...... UK Parliament Week, 14th-20th November 2022! Already 2,000 organisations have signed up via www.ukparliamentweek.org/en/ including my office, will you? ... See MoreSee Less
    View on Facebook
    · Share

    Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

    John Stevenson MP

    2 hours ago

    John Stevenson MP
    www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/20151175.john-stevenson-looks-forward-jubilee-weekend-carlisle/ ... See MoreSee Less

    City to come together to celebrate Platinum Jubilee

    www.newsandstar.co.uk

    WITH less than two weeks to go to the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee weekend, Carlisle has come together to offer a range of exciting events and...
    View on Facebook
    · Share

    Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

    About

    JOHN STEVENSON

    John was educated at Aberdeen Grammar School and Dundee University. John subsequently qualified as a solicitor in 1990. In 2010 John was elected Conservative MP for Carlisle and was re-elected with an increased majority in 2015. John was re-elected again in 2017 and 2019 with a new majority of 8319. Carlisle is the only city in Cumbria and John enjoys representing a constituency at Westminster with such a strong identity.

    Latest Posts
    19th May 2022

    John Stevenson looks forward to an Action Packed Jubilee Weekend in Carlisle

    19th May 2022

    John Stevenson Re-elected to Chair the Parliamentary Food and Drink Group

    17th May 2022

    John Stevenson Thanks Veterans from across the Country and Cumbria’s Residents for their Support with Carlisle’s Falklands 40 Commemorative Event

    Photo Gallery
    John carries Commemorative Rose at Falklands Events
    John with Students on Dream Week Placement
    John with Mark Jenkinson MP and Cumbria Order
    John with Clark Door Limited supporting Family Business
    John with Rob and Claire Story of Story Decorating
    John attending meeting at Carlisle Cathedral celebrating EnglishTourismWeek21, which included tourism businesses from across Carlisle
    John and Chairman of Cumbria Tourism, Jim Walker, at restaurant during the 'Eat out to Help out' scheme
    John and Chairman of Cumbria Tourism, Jim Walker, at restaurant during the 'Eat out to Help out' scheme
    John at Carlisle Skills Fair 2020
    John at Carlisle Skills Fair 2020
    John at Carlisle Skills Fair 2020
    John at Carlisle Skills Fair 2020
    Copyright © 2015 JOHN STEVENSON. This website is funded from Parliamentary Allowances.
    • About John
    • Privacy Notice
    • Get In Touch

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.